Wet weather, trade shortages, late materials and slow approvals can all push the completion of a home build back, and the owner pays rent or a second mortgage while they wait. Whether any of that cost can be recovered depends largely on the contract.
The completion date
A level 2 regulated contract in Queensland must state the date for practical completion, or the number of days the work will take from commencement. That date is the benchmark against which delay is measured. If the contract gives a number of days, the date is calculated from the actual commencement, so a late start moves the finish line. Many disputes about delay begin with a disagreement about when the contract actually started.
Extensions of time
Standard contracts list the events that entitle the contractor to an extension of time: inclement weather beyond an allowance already built into the period, variations, delays caused by the owner or the owner’s consultants, latent conditions, industrial action, and delays in approvals or utility connections that are not the contractor’s fault. Section 42 of Schedule 1B to the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 adds its own conditions. A contractor under a regulated contract may claim an extension only where the delay was not reasonably foreseeable and was beyond the contractor’s reasonable control, was caused by the owner, or was caused by a properly documented variation. The claim must be made in writing and given to the owner within 10 business days after the contractor became aware, or ought reasonably to have become aware, of the cause and extent of the delay, and the owner must approve it in writing.
Two points matter in practice. First, a contractor who does not claim in time may lose the entitlement, and owners should check the dates on every claim. Second, an owner’s silence is not approval under the Act. Under the QBCC’s standard new home construction contract the owner has 10 business days to assess the claim and respond, and a claim that is not answered is deemed to be disputed. An owner who unreasonably rejects a valid claim may be liable to the contractor for damages. Both sides should respond to extension claims in writing and on time.
Liquidated damages
Liquidated damages are the pre agreed amount the owner can deduct from the contract price for each day of delay beyond the completion date, as extended. The figure is inserted in the contract schedule when it is signed. Where a realistic figure has been agreed, such as an amount reflecting the owner’s likely rent, it is enforceable without proof of the actual loss. Where a nominal figure such as $50 a day is inserted, owners are generally held to that amount and cannot recover their larger actual loss as general damages instead, because the parties agreed the measure in advance. Where the schedule is left blank, the answer depends on the wording of the particular contract. Some standard forms supply a default daily rate if nothing is inserted, while under others a blank or nil entry has been read as an agreement that there are no liquidated damages, which may leave the owner with a claim for general damages or, on some wordings, with no delay claim at all. The time to deal with this is before signing.
A liquidated damages clause that is extravagant and out of all proportion to any likely loss may be struck down as a penalty, which is rare in domestic contracts because the amounts are usually modest.
Contracts without delay provisions
Where a contract says nothing about time, the contractor must complete within a reasonable time, and an owner who can prove the contractor exceeded it can claim general damages for the resulting loss. Proving what was reasonable, and that the delay caused the loss, is harder than relying on an agreed date and figure, which is why the regulated contract requirements exist.
Owner caused delay
Owners cause delays too: late selections of fittings, slow responses to requests for information, failure to pay a progress claim on time, and changes to the design. Each of these entitles the contractor to claim an extension, and under some contracts to delay costs for the additional period on site. An owner who is behind on decisions cannot then deduct liquidated damages for the resulting delay.
Suspension and termination
Persistent delay can become a breach that supports termination, usually through the notice to remedy process the contract sets out. The breach relied on is commonly failure to proceed with reasonable diligence, and the evidence is the record of progress: site diaries, photographs and the correspondence about the program. A single missed date is rarely enough; a pattern of inactivity and unexplained absence from site is.
Managing a delayed job
Keep a dated record of progress with photographs. Respond in writing to every extension claim, agreeing or disputing it with reasons. Calculate the extended completion date as claims are accepted so that both sides know where they stand. Deduct liquidated damages from the final claim rather than withholding progress payments, which can put the owner in breach. And raise concerns about the pace of work early and in writing.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.