Money is the pressure point on every building job. The contractor needs cash flow to pay suppliers and trades; the owner needs assurance that the money is paying for work that has been done. Schedule 1B of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 strikes the balance with rules about deposits and progress payments that both sides should know.
Deposits
A contractor may not demand or receive a deposit above the statutory cap. For a contract with a price under $20,000 the cap is 10 per cent. For a contract of $20,000 or more it is 5 per cent. The $20,000 figure is the level 2 amount prescribed by regulation. Where the value of work to be performed off site, such as fabricating a kit home or joinery in a factory, exceeds half of the contract price, the cap is 20 per cent. A contractor who demands or receives more than the cap commits an offence. Owners should check this before paying, because the home warranty scheme does not cover the part of a deposit above the cap and a large deposit paid to a contractor who later fails is often unrecoverable in practice.
Progress payments
The Schedule requires that a progress payment claimed under a regulated contract be directly related to the progress of the work. A claim must be for work that has been carried out or materials that have been supplied, and must not be for more than the value of what has been done. Where a contract sets stage payments, the stages and the amounts attached to them should be proportionate to the work in each stage. A contract that front loads payments, for example by attaching 40 per cent of the price to the slab stage, is open to challenge, and the QBCC treats claiming for work not done as a serious matter.
The contract will specify when claims can be made and how long the owner has to pay. Standard form contracts commonly allow five business days. The contractor is entitled to be paid on time for a properly made claim, and most contracts allow it to suspend work, charge interest and ultimately terminate if payment is not made.
Adjudication does not apply to a home you live in
The rapid payment claim and adjudication process under the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 does not apply to a contract for domestic building work between a contractor and a resident owner, to the extent the contract relates to a home the owner lives in or intends to live in. A dispute about a progress claim on your own home is therefore resolved under the contract and, if necessary, in QCAT or the courts rather than by an adjudicator. Investors who will not live in the property, and subcontractors on a home, do fall within that Act, and its strict timeframes for payment schedules apply to them.
When a claim is disputed
Owners should not simply stop paying because they are unhappy with something. The safer course is to pay the undisputed portion and set out, in writing and within the time the contract allows, which items are disputed and why. Common grounds are that a stage has not been reached, that work claimed has not been done, or that the claim includes variations the owner did not request or agree to. A written response protects the owner from a later argument that payment was wrongfully withheld, and it creates the record QCAT will look at.
Where the owner withholds the whole of a properly made claim, the contractor’s remedies under the contract come into play. A suspension stops work and extends the completion date; a termination for non payment lets the contractor leave the job and claim for the work done plus loss of profit on the remainder. Owners who are in dispute about a payment but want the job finished should be careful not to hand the contractor a termination right.
Claims for work not done
The reverse problem is a contractor who claims a stage before it is reached, or who invoices for materials that have not been delivered. The owner can refuse the unsupported portion and should say why. If the contractor has already been paid for work not done and then abandons the job, the owner may be able to recover the overpayment in QCAT or the courts, and the QBCC can be told. Where the contract has been lawfully terminated because of the contractor’s default, the home warranty scheme may respond to non completion, subject to its conditions and time limits.
Final payment and practical completion
The final payment is usually tied to practical completion, when the work is complete apart from minor omissions and defects and the home can be used for its purpose. Disputes often arise about whether that point has been reached and about retention of money for incomplete items. The contract defines practical completion, and an owner who disputes that it has been reached should identify the outstanding items in writing. Fox Piper does not act in disputes about the quality of the work itself, but whether a stage or completion has been reached is a contract question we can advise on.
Records
Every claim, every payment and every response should be kept, with photographs of the site at each stage. Building payment disputes are decided on those records.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- QBCC, Understanding deposits and progress payments
- QBCC, Contracts and agreement types
- Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), schedule 1B, ss 33 and 34 (deposits and progress payments)
- Queensland Building and Construction Commission Regulation 2018 (Qld), s 45 (level 2 amount) and schedule 6, s 5 (insurable deposit)
- Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld), s 61(2)(b)