- Home
- What we help with
- Building and renovation
- Variations and progress payments
Variations and progress payments
The invoice arrives and it is nothing like the contract. Extra items the owner does not remember agreeing to, a progress claim for a stage that is nowhere near finished, or a contractor who did the extra work in good faith and is now being told it will never be paid for. The law has specific answers to each of these. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on where you stand.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- Variations in writingThe contractor must put a variation in writing, describing the change and its effect on the price and time, and must not start the varied work before the owner agrees to it in writing.
- Recovering a variationFailing to document a variation is an offence but no longer bars payment. A contractor can generally recover a reasonable amount for extra work the owner requested or agreed to.
- Progress paymentsA progress claim must relate directly to work already carried out and be proportionate to it. Claims ahead of the work are prohibited.
- ForumQCAT decides domestic building payment disputes with no monetary limit, after the QBCC's dispute resolution process.
The disputes we see most
- The contractor is invoicing for variations the owner never signed, or says were agreed on site.
- The owner asked for changes verbally, the work was done, and now the owner refuses to pay for it.
- A progress claim has been issued for a stage that is incomplete, or the contract stages do not match the work actually done.
- The owner has paid more than the value of the work completed and the contractor has walked off.
- The contractor has suspended work for non payment of an amount the owner disputes.
- The final invoice includes charges for prime cost and provisional sum items that are far higher than the allowances in the contract.
How variations must be handled
Schedule 1B of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 treats variations as a formal step, not a conversation. The contractor must put a variation to a domestic building contract in writing, in a document that describes the variation, the date it was requested, any delay it will cause, the change to the contract price or the method of calculating it, and when the change is to be paid or credited. The contractor must give the owner a copy within 5 business days after the variation is agreed and before the varied work starts, and must not start that work until the owner has agreed to the variation in writing. It is a defence to the requirement to give the document first that the work was required urgently and it was not reasonably practicable to produce it beforehand.
A contractor who has not complied commits an offence, but is no longer barred from being paid. The former rule that an undocumented variation could be recovered only with the tribunal’s approval was repealed in 2015, and the Act now provides that non compliance does not make the contract unenforceable. Where the owner requested or agreed to the extra work, the contractor can generally recover for it, at a reasonable price if none was agreed. Where the owner did not, the contractor is not entitled to be paid merely because the owner has the benefit of the work. Whether a change was requested, and what it was reasonably worth, are the questions on which most variation disputes turn.
How progress payments must be handled
The Schedule prohibits a contractor from claiming a progress payment that is not directly related to the progress of the work and proportionate to the value of the work carried out, and from requiring payment for a variation before the varied work has started. Most contracts divide the work into stages with a payment due at the completion of each. Whether a stage is complete is a question of fact, usually answered by photographs and the contract’s definition of the stage. An owner may withhold a payment claimed early, and a contractor who claims early may lose the right to suspend for non payment. The contractor warrants that prime cost items and provisional sums have been calculated with reasonable care and skill, and the contract sets out how the difference between the allowance and the actual cost is adjusted.
Where these disputes are decided
Domestic building payment disputes go to QCAT after the QBCC’s dispute resolution process has been completed. There is no monetary limit for domestic building work. Where a contract has ended and the dispute is only about a debt, a claim in the Magistrates Court may also be available, but the QBCC and QCAT route is usual.
What usually happens
A reconciliation of the account against the contract, setting out which claims are properly payable and which are not, is often enough to resolve the dispute, because both sides can then see what a tribunal would be likely to order. Where it does not, the QBCC process and a QCAT application follow, and we quote each step before you commit to it.
What we do not do
We do not act in defective work disputes or in payment claims between head contractors and subcontractors under the security of payment legislation.
What we do
- Compare the invoices and variations against the contract and Schedule 1B and advise you in writing on what is properly payable and what is not.
- Prepare letters disputing or supporting claims, and negotiate a reconciliation of the account so the work can continue or the contract can be brought to an orderly end.
- Take the dispute through the QBCC's dispute resolution process and prepare the QCAT application or response, including the schedule of claims and the evidence.
- Act for contractors seeking payment for variations that were requested or agreed but not properly documented.
Common questions
The builder did extra work I asked for but nothing was signed. Do I have to pay?
In many cases, yes. The law places the obligation to document a variation on the contractor, and failing to do so is an offence. But since 2015 the Act has not barred a contractor from being paid for an undocumented variation. Where an owner asked for extra work, the ordinary inference is that it will be paid for, at a reasonable price if none was agreed. The position is different where the owner never requested or agreed to the work, or where the contract makes written approval a condition of payment.
What does a variation document have to contain?
It must be legible, describe the variation, and state the date it was requested, the contractor's reasonable estimate of any delay, the change to the contract price or how it will be worked out, and when any increase is to be paid or any decrease credited. The contractor must give the owner a copy within 5 business days after the variation is agreed and before the varied work starts, and must not start that work until the owner has agreed in writing. The Act does not require both parties to sign, although many contracts do. It is a defence to the requirement to give the document first that the work was urgent and it was not reasonably practicable to produce it beforehand.
Can the builder claim a stage payment before the stage is finished?
No. A progress payment claimed under a domestic building contract must be directly related to the progress of the work and proportionate to the value of the work actually carried out. Claiming a stage early is an offence, and an owner is entitled to withhold payment until the stage is complete. The contract usually defines each stage, so the question is whether the defined work has in fact been done.
I have paid ahead and the builder has stopped. Can I get the money back?
Potentially. An owner who has paid more than the value of the work completed may be able to recover the overpayment from the contractor, and the claim can be brought in QCAT after the QBCC process. If the contractor is insolvent, the QBCC's home warranty scheme may respond to a non completion claim, which is dealt with on our QBCC complaints page.
Can the builder suspend the work because I disputed an invoice?
Most contracts allow the contractor to suspend work if a progress claim is not paid when due, but only where the claim was validly made. If the claim was for work not yet done, or for a variation the owner never requested or agreed to, the right to suspend may not arise and the suspension may itself be a breach. These situations escalate quickly, so get advice before refusing payment or walking away.
What are prime cost items and provisional sums?
Prime cost items are allowances for things like tiles and fittings that the owner has not yet selected. Provisional sums are allowances for work whose extent cannot be fixed at contract, such as excavation. The contract must state each allowance, and the contractor warrants that it was calculated with reasonable care and skill. The contractor can charge the actual cost plus any margin the contract allows, with the difference from the allowance adjusted as the contract provides, but an allowance that was never realistic can be challenged.
Articles on variations and progress payments
Longer answers to the questions people ask us most often about variations and progress payments. Each one sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
- Variations must be in writing: section 40 and the cost of informal changes on a building jobQueensland law requires a variation to a domestic building contract to be put in writing and agreed to in writing by the owner before the work starts. This article explains the requirements in Schedule 1B of the QBCC Act, whether a contractor can still be paid for an undocumented variation and how owners should respond to a claim.
- Progress payments and deposits: what a Queensland builder can ask for and whenQueensland caps deposits on home building contracts and requires progress payments to reflect work actually done. This article explains the deposit limits, the rules for progress claims, what an owner can do about a claim for work not yet performed and the risk of withholding payment.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.