Few decisions in a building dispute carry more risk than terminating the contract. Done properly, termination lets an owner replace a contractor who has stopped performing, or lets a contractor leave a job where the owner has stopped paying. Done improperly, it turns the terminating party into the party in breach. In Queensland the mechanics come from the contract itself and the general law.
Contractual termination
Domestic building contracts usually contain a termination clause, and most follow the same pattern. The party alleging a substantial breach gives a written notice identifying the breach and requiring it to be remedied within a stated period, often 10 business days. If the breach is not remedied in that time, the party may give a second notice terminating the contract. Breaches that commonly justify the process include failure to proceed with reasonable diligence, suspension of work without proper grounds and failure to pay a progress claim.
The notices must be given strictly in accordance with the contract: in writing, to the address or email the contract specifies, identifying the breach with enough detail that the recipient knows what to fix, and allowing the full period. A notice that describes the complaint vaguely, or a termination given a day early, is usually ineffective. Where the breach is remedied within the period, the right to terminate for that breach is lost.
Termination at common law
A party may also terminate at common law where the other party has repudiated the contract, meaning they have shown by words or conduct that they no longer intend to be bound by it or to perform it in a way that matters. A contractor who walks off site and says it will not return, or an owner who refuses to pay anything further and locks the gate, has repudiated. Serious breaches of essential terms can also justify termination without the notice procedure. The threshold is high, and a party who treats slow progress or a disputed invoice as repudiation will often be found to have gone too far.
Wrongful termination
The consequence of getting it wrong is that the purported termination is itself a repudiation. The other party can accept it, bring the contract to an end and claim damages. An owner who wrongly terminates can end up paying the contractor’s lost profit on the remainder of the job as well as for the work done. A contractor who wrongly terminates can end up paying the owner’s additional cost of completing with another builder. Before any notice is sent, the breach relied on, the notice provisions and the evidence should all be checked.
What each side can claim afterwards
Where an owner validly terminates for the contractor’s default, the owner can recover the reasonable additional cost of having the work completed by another contractor, less the unpaid balance of the original contract price, together with the cost of rectifying work and any delay losses the contract allows. The QBCC home warranty scheme may also respond to non completion where the contract was lawfully terminated because of the contractor’s default, subject to the scheme’s conditions and time limits, and a claim should be lodged promptly.
Where a contractor validly terminates for the owner’s default, the contractor can recover payment for the work done and materials supplied up to termination, and damages for the profit it would have made on the remainder of the contract. The contractor must prove the margin it would have earned.
QCAT and the QBCC process
Disputes about termination of a domestic building contract are usually decided in QCAT, which has no monetary limit for domestic building disputes. Before an application can be filed the parties must have gone through the QBCC’s dispute resolution process and obtained its letter confirming that the process has concluded. The respondent then has 14 days to respond to the application. Commercial building disputes above $50,000 require the consent of the parties for QCAT to deal with them, otherwise they go to the courts.
Before you terminate
Read the termination clause, identify the breach precisely, assemble the evidence, give the first notice properly and diarise the remedy period. Consider whether a suspension or a negotiated exit achieves what you need with less risk. And if you receive a notice, respond in writing within the period, either remedying the breach or explaining why there is none.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.