The will was read a year ago and nothing has arrived. The executor does not return calls. Beneficiaries in this position want to know whether the delay is normal, whether they are owed anything for the wait and when they can do something about it. The answers are reasonably clear.
The executor’s duties
Section 52(1) of the Succession Act 1981 requires a personal representative to collect and get in the deceased’s real and personal estate and administer it according to law, to provide an inventory and account when the court requires it, to deliver up the grant when required, and to distribute the estate, subject to its administration, as soon as may be. The duty is to proceed with reasonable diligence given the nature of the estate, not to distribute by a fixed date.
The executor’s year
The law has long allowed an executor a year from the death to administer the estate before beneficiaries can insist on payment. Section 52(1A) preserves the rules and practices deriving from the executor’s year. A beneficiary who demands distribution six months after the death has no entitlement to it; a beneficiary still waiting at eighteen months, with no explanation, has a legitimate complaint.
The year is not a licence to do nothing. An executor should obtain the grant of probate, identify and secure the assets, notify institutions, advertise for creditors, lodge tax returns and pay debts during it. A simple estate of a house and bank accounts can be fully administered within the year. A complex estate with a business, overseas assets, disputes or a family provision claim cannot, and the year is a starting point rather than a deadline.
Interest on legacies
Under section 52(1)(e), a general legacy, meaning a gift of a sum of money, carries interest from the first anniversary of the death until payment at 8 per cent a year, or another rate the court determines, unless the will shows a contrary intention. A legacy payable at a future date under the will carries interest from that date. Residuary beneficiaries receive the income actually earned by the residue. A beneficiary of a $50,000 legacy still unpaid two years after death is entitled to a further year’s interest, which is a useful point to make in correspondence with a slow executor.
The family provision waiting periods
Executors have a good reason for not distributing in the first six months. Under section 44(3), an executor who distributes after six months from the death without having received notice of an intended family provision application is protected from liability to an applicant. If notice is received, the executor should wait until nine months from the death, and should not distribute without advice if by then they have received written notice that an application has been commenced or have been served with a copy of it. Beneficiaries should expect no distribution before six months for this reason alone.
Legitimate reasons for delay
Estates take longer where probate is contested or a caveat has been lodged; where property must be sold in a slow market; where a business must be wound up or transferred; where there are overseas assets requiring foreign grants; where tax matters, including capital gains on assets sold during administration, must be finalised; where a beneficiary cannot be located or is a minor; where a creditor has made a claim; and where a family provision or estoppel claim is on foot. An executor dealing with any of these should say so, and a beneficiary told the reason usually accepts it.
When delay becomes actionable
Delay becomes a breach when it is unreasonable in the circumstances and causes loss, or when it reflects an executor’s refusal or inability to act. The signs are an executor who does not respond to reasonable requests for information, who has not applied for probate many months after the death, who is using estate property or funds, who is in conflict with the estate’s interests or who has simply stopped. Beneficiaries can then ask the Supreme Court to order the executor to file and pass accounts, to answer specific questions, to distribute, or, in serious cases, to revoke the grant and appoint someone else.
Interim distributions are also possible. Where the estate is clearly solvent and the only remaining uncertainty is small, an executor can distribute most of the estate and retain a reserve, and a beneficiary can ask for that.
Practical steps for beneficiaries
Write to the executor asking for a summary of the assets and liabilities, what has been done, what remains and the expected timetable. Keep the request courteous and specific. If no answer comes within a reasonable time, a letter from a lawyer referring to the executor’s duties and the court’s powers usually does. Court applications are the last step and their cost should be weighed against the delay.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.