A testator chooses an executor expecting loyalty and competence. Sometimes the choice turns out badly: the executor does nothing, falls out with the beneficiaries, moves into the deceased’s house, or has interests opposed to the estate. The Supreme Court can remove an executor, but it does not do so lightly, and the grounds and the process need to be understood before any application is made.
The court’s power
Section 6 of the Succession Act 1981 gives the Supreme Court jurisdiction in every respect that may be convenient to grant and revoke probate or letters of administration, to hear and determine matters relating to estates and their administration, and to make the orders necessary for those purposes. Revocation of a grant and the appointment of a new administrator is the mechanism for removing an executor who already holds probate. The guiding question is whether the due and proper administration of the estate and the interests of the beneficiaries as a whole require the removal. The testator’s choice carries weight, and friction between an executor and beneficiaries is not enough on its own. A recent illustration is Renton v Dresselhaus [2026] QSC 95, where the Supreme Court removed all four executors, who were sisters split into two factions, revoked probate and appointed an independent solicitor as administrator. The court accepted that friction and hostility are not themselves grounds for removal, but found that the breakdown of trust meant the executors could not act unanimously, that delay and inefficiency would follow and that the due administration of the estate would be frustrated if they stayed in office, at [80] to [94].
Grounds that succeed
The grounds on which courts have removed executors include a refusal or inability to carry out the duties of the office, including through ill health or absence; unreasonable and unexplained delay in administering the estate; failure to keep or provide accounts and information when properly asked; using estate assets for the executor’s own benefit, including living in estate property without paying for it; a conflict between the executor’s personal interests and the estate, such as a disputed debt the executor owes or claims, or a competing claim to estate property; dishonesty or misconduct; and a breakdown in relations so complete that the estate cannot be administered, where the executor bears responsibility for it. Each case turns on evidence, and the applicant must show the facts, not merely assert distrust.
Executors who have not taken out probate
Where a named executor has not applied for probate and will not say whether they intend to, the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules allow an interested person to issue a citation requiring the executor to apply for a grant or to renounce. An executor who does neither can be passed over, and the court can grant letters of administration with the will annexed to another person, usually a beneficiary or an independent administrator. An executor who has intermeddled in the estate cannot simply walk away by renouncing, and may be compelled to take the grant or be removed.
Who replaces the executor
The court appoints the person best placed to administer the estate: a co executor who remains, the beneficiaries’ nominee, an independent solicitor or accountant, or the Public Trustee. Where the beneficiaries are at war with each other, an independent administrator is the usual outcome, and the costs of that administrator come from the estate. Applicants should propose a suitable replacement who has consented in writing.
Once the executor becomes a trustee
An executor’s role changes when administration is complete and the assets are held for beneficiaries, for example under a testamentary trust or for a minor. At that point the executor holds as trustee, and the Trusts Act 2025, which commenced on 28 April 2026 and replaced the Trusts Act 1973, applies. The Act applies to a personal representative only where they are acting as trustee after completing the administration of the estate or part of it. The court’s power to remove a trustee and appoint a replacement under section 166 of the Act is then the relevant power, alongside the statutory duties the Act imposes: to act honestly and in good faith, to exercise care, diligence and skill, to keep accurate accounts and records under section 64 and, under section 65, to make the accounts available for inspection by a beneficiary within a reasonable period after a request. An application to remove a person as both executor and trustee can be brought in the one proceeding.
Costs
Costs in removal applications follow the usual rule that they are in the court’s discretion. An executor who has behaved properly and is removed for practical reasons, such as ill health or breakdown, generally has their costs paid from the estate. An executor removed for misconduct or unreasonable conduct can be ordered to pay the applicant’s costs personally. An applicant who brings an unjustified application can be ordered to pay the executor’s costs. The prospect of a personal costs order is the most effective lever for persuading a recalcitrant executor to resign, which is why a well founded letter often achieves what a court application would.
Before applying
Write to the executor setting out the concerns, asking for specific information and action within a reasonable time, and stating that an application will follow if it is not provided. Ask the executor to consider resigning in favour of an agreed independent administrator. Where the executor agrees, the court can make the orders by consent at a fraction of the cost.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.