Most disputes between beneficiaries and executors begin with silence. The beneficiary asks what is in the estate and hears nothing, or receives a figure with no detail. Suspicion follows. The law entitles beneficiaries to information, and executors who provide it promptly avoid most of the conflict that otherwise develops.
What a beneficiary is entitled to know
A residuary beneficiary, who takes what is left after debts and specific gifts, has an interest in the whole estate and is entitled to an account of it: the assets at death and their values, the liabilities, the receipts and payments during administration, the costs incurred and the proposed distribution. A specific legatee or a beneficiary of a fixed sum is entitled to information about their own gift, whether the estate can pay it and when, but not to a full account of the residue. A person who is not a beneficiary, such as a disappointed relative, has no entitlement to information from the executor, though they may obtain the will from the probate registry once a grant has been made and may have rights under the Succession Act to inspect the will.
Beneficiaries are entitled to see the will and the grant, the inventory of assets, bank statements for estate accounts on reasonable request, valuations, the sale documents for estate property and the executor’s accounts. They are not entitled to the executor’s privileged legal advice about a dispute with them, to the executor’s reasons for the exercise of a discretion where the will confers one, or to manage the administration.
The executor’s duty to account
Section 52(1)(b) of the Succession Act 1981 requires a personal representative, when required by the court, to exhibit on oath a full inventory of the estate and to render an account of the administration. The general law requires an executor to keep proper accounts and to be ready to produce them to beneficiaries on reasonable request. An executor who declines to provide information is in breach of that duty, and the Supreme Court can order the executor to file accounts in the registry and have them examined and passed, with the executor liable for the costs if the refusal was unreasonable.
The Trusts Act 2025
Where the executor has completed administration and holds assets as trustee, for example for a minor or under a testamentary trust, the Trusts Act 2025 applies. It commenced on 28 April 2026. Section 64 requires trustees to keep accurate accounts and records, and section 65 requires a trustee, on request by a beneficiary, to make the accounts available for inspection within a reasonable period, subject to limited exceptions where the request is unreasonable. A trustee who refuses can be ordered by the court to comply. These are statutory duties and the Act applies to trusts whenever created.
How to ask
Ask in writing, specifically. A request for everything invites refusal; a request for a schedule of assets and liabilities at death, a statement of receipts and payments to date, copies of the estate bank statements and an indication of the expected timetable is reasonable and hard to refuse. Allow a reasonable time, which for an executor with a solicitor is a few weeks. If the executor refuses or stalls, a letter from a lawyer setting out the duty and the court’s powers to order accounts and costs usually produces the information.
What the accounts may show
Accounts commonly reveal the matters that beneficiaries suspected: estate funds used for the executor’s expenses without authority, property sold to a relative at an undervalue, an executor’s commission charged without approval, legal costs that seem high, or delay with no activity. Each has a remedy. An executor must account for any benefit taken from the estate, can be surcharged for losses caused by breach of duty, needs the court’s or the beneficiaries’ approval to take commission unless the will provides for it, and can have their costs disallowed where they were not properly incurred.
When the executor is also a beneficiary
An executor who is also the main beneficiary has no lesser duty to account to the others, and the overlap of roles is where most conflicts arise. The executor’s personal share does not entitle them to treat the estate as their own before distribution, and the other beneficiaries’ entitlement to transparency is unchanged.
Court orders
Where correspondence fails, the Supreme Court can order the executor to file an inventory and accounts, to answer specific questions on oath, to produce documents and to pay the costs of the application. The same application can seek orders for distribution or, in serious cases, removal. Courts expect beneficiaries to have asked properly first, and an application brought without a prior reasonable request risks costs.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.