- Home
- What we help with
- Wills, estates and family provision
- Disputes between beneficiaries
Disputes between beneficiaries
The will is valid and the executor is doing their job, but the beneficiaries cannot agree. One sibling wants to sell the house and another wants to buy it or keep living in it. The will leaves the contents to one child and nobody agrees what the contents are. Dad lent one brother $200,000 years ago and the others say it should come off his share. These disputes are about what the will means and what the law does with assets the will does not reach, and most can be resolved without a hearing. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on where you stand.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- InterpretationWhere the words of a will are unclear, the court decides what the will maker meant, and can look at evidence of their circumstances and in some cases their intentions.
- Outside the estateJointly held property passes to the survivor and superannuation is paid by the fund trustee. Neither usually passes under the will unless the will maker arranged it.
- Lifetime gifts and loansA loan to a beneficiary remains an estate asset that is set off against their share. A gift does not, unless the will says it should be brought into account.
- CourtThe Supreme Court decides questions about the meaning and administration of a will. Many disputes are resolved by agreement recorded in a deed.
The disputes we see most
- Beneficiaries disagree about whether the family home should be sold or who may buy it and at what price.
- A beneficiary is living in estate property and will not move out or pay rent.
- The will's wording is unclear and the beneficiaries read it differently.
- One beneficiary received substantial gifts or loans during the deceased's life and the others want them taken into account.
- A superannuation death benefit or a jointly held account has gone to one person and the others say it should be shared.
- The deceased promised an asset to someone during life and the will does not reflect the promise.
What the will means
An executor must administer the estate according to the proper meaning of the will, and beneficiaries frequently read the same words differently. Whether a gift of the contents of the house includes the car in the garage, whether a gift to my children includes stepchildren, whether a gift lapses because the beneficiary died first, and who takes a share the will does not deal with are all questions of construction. The Supreme Court resolves them by reading the will as a whole in the light of the will maker’s circumstances, and where the language is ambiguous it may consider evidence of the will maker’s intention. Where the will fails to carry out the will maker’s intentions because of a clerical error or because it does not give effect to their instructions, the court can rectify it, but an application for rectification must generally be made within 6 months of the death unless the court extends time and the estate has not been distributed.
Assets inside and outside the estate
Many beneficiary disputes are really about assets that do not pass under the will at all. Property held as joint tenants passes to the survivor by survivorship. Superannuation death benefits are paid by the fund trustee, under a binding nomination if one is valid and otherwise at the trustee’s discretion among dependants and the estate, and a person who disagrees with the trustee’s decision must object to the trustee and then complain to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority within short time limits. Joint bank accounts raise the question whether the deceased intended the survivor to take the balance or merely added them for convenience. Loans the deceased made to a beneficiary remain estate assets and are set off against that beneficiary’s share, whereas gifts are not brought into account unless the will directs it. Promises the deceased made during life about who would receive property can sometimes be enforced against the estate by estoppel where the person relied on the promise to their detriment.
The family home
The most common dispute is about the house. Where it is left to several beneficiaries, the executor must ordinarily sell it and divide the proceeds unless the will provides otherwise or the beneficiaries agree. A beneficiary who wishes to keep it can buy out the others at market value, and a beneficiary occupying it to the exclusion of the others can be required to give possession and to pay an occupation fee. The will may give a right of residence or an option to purchase, and the terms of those rights are often the real argument.
Where these disputes are decided
The Supreme Court of Queensland decides questions about the meaning and administration of a will and can give directions to an executor. Most disputes between beneficiaries are resolved by negotiation or mediation and recorded in a deed of family arrangement, which varies the will by agreement and binds everyone who signs it. The costs of a genuine construction question are often paid from the estate, but a beneficiary who takes an unreasonable position may bear their own.
What usually happens
Our first step is a written advice on what the will means, what is in and outside the estate and how the law treats the asset or the promise in dispute. That advice often lets the beneficiaries settle the question between themselves. Where it does not, we negotiate, document any agreement and, if necessary, prepare the application to the court, quoting each step before you commit to it.
What we do
- Advise you in writing on what the will means, what falls inside and outside the estate and how the law treats the asset or the promise in dispute.
- Negotiate with the other beneficiaries and the executor and document any agreement in a deed of family arrangement that binds everyone.
- Apply to the Supreme Court for the construction of the will or for directions where agreement is not possible.
- Pursue or defend claims about lifetime gifts, loans, promises, superannuation and jointly held assets.
Common questions
Can one beneficiary force the sale of the family home?
If the house is left to several beneficiaries, the executor usually has a duty to realise it and distribute the proceeds unless the will gives a right of occupation or an option to purchase, or all beneficiaries agree otherwise. A beneficiary who wants to keep the house can usually buy out the others at market value, and that is a common resolution. A beneficiary who refuses to leave and refuses to buy can be required to give possession, and can be charged an occupation fee for the period they excluded the others.
The will is ambiguous. Who decides what it means?
The executor must administer the will according to its proper meaning, and if the beneficiaries disagree the Supreme Court can determine the construction. The court reads the will as a whole, gives words their ordinary meaning in the context of the will maker's circumstances, and can consider evidence of those circumstances and, where the words are ambiguous, evidence of the will maker's intention. Where the will contains a clerical error or does not give effect to the will maker's instructions, the court can rectify it, but an application to rectify must generally be made within 6 months of the death.
My brother was lent money by Dad. Does it come off his share?
If it was a loan, yes. A debt owed by a beneficiary to the deceased is an estate asset, and the executor must set it off against the beneficiary's share even if the debt is otherwise too old to sue on. If it was a gift, it is not brought into account unless the will says so. Whether a payment was a loan or a gift is a question of fact, and the evidence is in the documents, the bank records and what the parties said and did at the time.
What about superannuation and joint accounts?
Superannuation does not usually form part of the estate. The fund trustee pays the death benefit according to a binding nomination if there is a valid one, and otherwise exercises its own discretion among the dependants and the estate. A person unhappy with the trustee's decision can object to the trustee and then complain to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, within short time limits. Property held as joint tenants passes to the surviving joint tenant automatically and outside the will. Bank accounts in joint names are more complicated, because the question is whether the deceased intended the survivor to take the money or merely added them for convenience.
Dad promised me the farm if I worked it. The will says otherwise. Do I have a claim?
Possibly. Where a person makes a clear promise about property, the other relies on it to their detriment, for example by working for years for little pay or giving up other opportunities, and it would be unconscionable for the promise to be withdrawn, the court can enforce the promise against the estate under the doctrine of estoppel. These claims depend heavily on evidence of the promise and of the reliance. They can be brought alongside a family provision claim, but they are not subject to the same 9 month deadline.
How are these disputes usually resolved?
Most are resolved by agreement. Beneficiaries can vary the terms of a will by a deed of family arrangement signed by everyone affected, and that is the usual outcome of a mediation or a negotiation. Where agreement is not possible, the executor or a beneficiary can apply to the Supreme Court for the construction of the will or for directions, and the court decides. Costs of a genuine construction question are often paid from the estate, but a beneficiary who takes an unreasonable position can be ordered to bear their own.
Articles on disputes between beneficiaries
A longer answer to one of the questions people ask us most often about disputes between beneficiaries. It sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.