- Home
- What we help with
- Wills, estates and family provision
- Challenges to the validity of a will
Challenges to the validity of a will
A new will signed in the last months of life, prepared by the beneficiary's solicitor, leaving everything to the person who was looking after the will maker, while the rest of the family found out after the funeral. Sometimes that is exactly what the will maker wanted. Sometimes it is not, and the law provides ways to test it. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on whether there is a real basis to challenge the will, or to defend it.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- CapacityThe will maker must have understood what a will does, the extent of their property and the people with claims on them, and must not have been affected by a disorder of the mind that distorted their decisions.
- Knowledge and approvalThe will maker must have known and approved the contents. Where the person who benefits prepared or arranged the will, the court requires that to be affirmatively proved.
- Undue influencePersuasion is not enough. A will is invalid for undue influence only where the will maker's own judgment was overborne so that the will reflects someone else's wishes.
- FormalitiesA will must be in writing and signed by the will maker in the presence of 2 witnesses, but the court can admit a document that does not comply if satisfied it was intended to be the will.
The disputes we see most
- A new will made late in life, when the will maker was unwell or had dementia, departs from long standing plans.
- The person who benefits organised the solicitor, drove the will maker to the appointment or was present when instructions were given.
- The signature looks wrong, the witnesses are connected to a beneficiary or the circumstances of signing are unclear.
- A later document, note or unsigned draft suggests the will maker's wishes changed.
- The original will cannot be found and only a copy exists.
- You are the executor or a beneficiary of a will that someone else is attacking.
The grounds for a challenge
A will is valid in Queensland if the will maker had testamentary capacity, knew and approved its contents, made it freely and executed it in accordance with the Succession Act 1981, which requires a written document signed by the will maker, or by someone at their direction and in their presence, in the presence of two witnesses present at the same time who also sign. A will can be challenged on the grounds that the will maker lacked capacity, did not know and approve the contents, was coerced by undue influence, was deceived by fraud, or did not validly execute it. A will that is merely unfair, or that departs from earlier promises, is not invalid for that reason, although the person disappointed may have a family provision claim or a claim based on the promise.
Capacity, knowledge and approval
Testamentary capacity requires that the will maker understood the nature and effect of making a will, the extent of the property being disposed of and the claims of the people who might expect to benefit, and was not affected by a disorder of the mind or a delusion that influenced the dispositions. A will that is rational on its face and duly executed is presumed to have been made by a capable person, but once real doubt is raised the person propounding the will must prove capacity, and the evidence is found in the medical records, the solicitor’s file and the accounts of those who saw the will maker. Knowledge and approval is normally inferred from capacity and execution, but where a substantial beneficiary was involved in preparing or arranging the will, the court treats the circumstances as suspicious and requires affirmative proof that the will maker knew and approved what the will said. Undue influence in this context means coercion that overbore the will maker’s judgment, not mere persuasion, and the person alleging it must prove it.
Informal documents, lost wills and rectification
The court can admit a document that does not meet the formal requirements if satisfied that the deceased intended it to be their will, an alteration or a revocation, and it can consider evidence of how the document was made and of the deceased’s statements. Where an original will cannot be found, the presumption is that the will maker destroyed it with the intention of revoking it, but the presumption can be rebutted and a copy admitted on evidence of the will’s contents and the circumstances. Where a valid will contains a clerical error or does not give effect to the will maker’s instructions, the court can rectify it, on an application made within 6 months of the death unless the court extends time before the estate is distributed.
Caveats and proceedings
A person with an interest in challenging a will can lodge a caveat in the Supreme Court, which prevents a grant of probate being made without notice to them. The executor must then seek the caveator’s withdrawal or apply to the court, and where there is a genuine question of validity the will must be proved in solemn form, with the evidence tested. Caveats should be lodged only on reasonable grounds, because the costs of unjustified delay fall on the caveator. Where the challenge arises from the will maker’s own conduct or the circumstances of the will, the costs of a reasonable investigation may be paid from the estate even if the challenge does not succeed, but an unreasonable challenge will usually attract a costs order. Most challenges resolve at mediation once the solicitor’s file and medical records have been obtained and both sides can see the evidence.
What usually happens
Our first step is a written advice on whether there is a real basis to challenge the will, or how strong the defence is, and the costs risk of each. Where a challenge has merit we lodge the caveat, obtain the file and the records and put the case to the other side. Where you are defending a will, we gather the evidence of capacity and the circumstances of execution. We quote each step before you commit to it.
What we do
- Assess the grounds for a challenge or the strength of a defence, and advise you in writing before any step is taken.
- Lodge a caveat so that no grant is made without notice, and obtain the solicitor's file and the medical records that decide most of these cases.
- Act in proceedings for a grant in solemn form, for the admission of an informal document, for a lost will or for rectification.
- Represent executors and beneficiaries defending a will against a challenge.
Common questions
What makes a will invalid?
A will can be set aside if the will maker lacked testamentary capacity, did not know and approve its contents, was subjected to undue influence or fraud, or if the document was not validly executed and the court declines to dispense with the formalities. It is not enough that the will is unfair, surprising or different from what was promised. Those complaints go to a family provision claim, not to validity, although both can be run together.
What is testamentary capacity?
At the time of giving instructions and signing, the will maker must have understood the nature and effect of making a will, the extent of the property being disposed of and the people who might reasonably expect to benefit, and must not have been affected by a disorder of the mind or delusion that influenced the dispositions. A diagnosis of dementia does not by itself mean a person lacked capacity, because capacity is judged at the time and in relation to the particular will. The evidence is in the medical records, the solicitor's file notes and the observations of people who saw the will maker around the time.
The beneficiary arranged the will. Does that matter?
Significantly. Where a person who takes a substantial benefit under a will was involved in its preparation, the court treats the circumstances as suspicious and requires the person propounding the will to prove affirmatively that the will maker knew and approved its contents. The more involved the beneficiary was and the more the will departs from previous wills, the heavier that burden becomes. Solicitors who take instructions from a beneficiary rather than the will maker, or who do not see the will maker alone, create exactly this problem.
What is undue influence in a will?
In the law of wills, undue influence means coercion: pressure that overbore the will maker's own judgment so that the will expresses someone else's wishes rather than theirs. Persuasion, appeals to affection or gratitude, and even persistent nagging are not undue influence if the will maker ultimately decided for themselves. It must be proved by the person alleging it, usually from circumstantial evidence, and it is a difficult ground on its own. In practice, a challenge usually rests on capacity and knowledge and approval, with undue influence as a supporting allegation where the facts justify it.
How do I stop the executor getting probate while this is sorted out?
By lodging a caveat in the Supreme Court. A caveat prevents a grant being made without notice to you, and the executor must then either persuade you to withdraw it or apply to the court, which will require the will to be proved in solemn form if there is a genuine question about validity. A caveat should not be lodged without reasonable grounds, because a caveator who causes delay without a proper basis can be ordered to pay costs. Lodging it early, and obtaining the solicitor's file and medical records promptly, is usually the first practical step.
Who pays the costs of a challenge?
The court's discretion. Where the will maker's own conduct or the circumstances of the will genuinely caused the challenge, the costs of a reasonable investigation may be ordered from the estate even if the challenge fails. Where the challenge was unreasonable, the unsuccessful party will usually pay. An executor who defends a will reasonably is usually indemnified from the estate. Because the costs risk is real on both sides, most challenges are resolved at mediation.
Articles on challenges to the validity of a will
Longer answers to the questions people ask us most often about challenges to the validity of a will. Each one sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
- Challenging a will: capacity, knowledge and approval, undue influence and probate caveatsA will can be set aside where the testator lacked capacity, did not know and approve its contents or was coerced. This article explains the tests Queensland courts apply, who bears the burden of proof and how a probate caveat prevents a grant while the challenge is investigated.
- Informal wills and rectification: when a document that is not a valid will can still take effectA will that was not signed or witnessed correctly, or that contains an error, is not necessarily lost. This article explains the Supreme Court's powers under sections 18 and 33 of the Succession Act 1981 to admit an informal document and to rectify a will, the evidence required and the six month time limit for rectification.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.