1. Home
  2. Articles
  3. Wills, estates and family provision
Wills, estates and family provision

Challenging a will: capacity, knowledge and approval, undue influence and probate caveats

A will can be set aside where the testator lacked capacity, did not know and approve its contents or was coerced. This article explains the tests Queensland courts apply, who bears the burden of proof and how a probate caveat prevents a grant while the challenge is investigated.

A new will made late in life that cuts out the family in favour of a carer, a neighbour or one child who arranged the solicitor raises an obvious question. Queensland law allows a will to be challenged on grounds that go to whether it truly reflects the deceased’s free and capable decision. Those grounds are narrower than many people assume, and the evidence that proves them is specific.

Testamentary capacity

A testator must have had testamentary capacity when the will was made. The test, settled in the nineteenth century and still applied, requires that the testator understood the nature of the act of making a will and its effects; understood in general terms the extent of the property being disposed of; was able to comprehend and weigh the claims of those who might expect to benefit; and was not affected by any disorder of the mind or insane delusion that influenced the dispositions. Capacity is judged at the time of giving instructions and executing the will, and a person with dementia may have capacity on a good day for a simple will while lacking it for a complex one.

The person seeking to uphold the will bears the burden of proving capacity once it is genuinely put in issue, although a will that is rational on its face and was duly executed is presumed to have been made by a capable testator until evidence raises a real doubt. Medical records, the evidence of the treating doctor and of the solicitor who took instructions, and the accounts of people who dealt with the testator around the time are the evidence. A solicitor’s file note recording that capacity was considered and how is often decisive either way.

Knowledge and approval

The testator must have known and approved the contents of the will. Where the will was read to or by a capable testator and executed, knowledge and approval is ordinarily presumed. Where there are suspicious circumstances, the presumption does not apply and the person propounding the will must affirmatively prove that the testator knew and approved it. The classic suspicious circumstance is a substantial beneficiary who prepared the will or arranged for its preparation. Others include a testator who could not read or whose English was poor, a will that departs radically from earlier ones without explanation, and secrecy around its making. The greater the suspicion, the stronger the evidence required to dispel it.

Undue influence

In probate, undue influence means coercion: pressure that overbore the testator’s own judgment so that the will expresses the wishes of another person rather than their own. Persuasion, appeals to affection or gratitude, and even persistent nagging are not undue influence if the testator was ultimately free to decide. The burden is on the person alleging it, and the standard is high because the alleged victim cannot give evidence. Undue influence is most often proved by circumstantial evidence: dependence, isolation from other family, control of the testator’s affairs by the beneficiary, and a will that cannot be explained otherwise. It is frequently alleged and rarely established on its own, which is why challenges usually combine it with capacity and knowledge and approval.

Fraud and forgery

A will procured by fraud, such as false statements about other family members made to induce the dispositions, or a forged will, is invalid. Forgery is proved by handwriting evidence and the circumstances of execution, and the witnesses to the will are the first people to be interviewed.

Probate caveats

A person with an interest in the estate who intends to challenge a will can lodge a caveat in the probate registry under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The caveat prevents a grant being made without notice to the caveator and gives time to investigate, including obtaining the medical records and the solicitor’s file. A caveat lasts for a limited period and can be renewed, and the person seeking the grant can apply to have it set aside if the caveator cannot show an interest in the estate and grounds for doubting that the grant should be made. A caveat lodged without proper grounds exposes the caveator to costs, so it should be used to protect a genuine investigation, not to delay.

Proving the will in solemn form

Where a challenge is maintained, the executor applies for probate in solemn form, and the matter proceeds as a contested trial in the Supreme Court with pleadings, disclosure of the medical and solicitor’s records, affidavits from the witnesses and expert evidence from geriatricians or psychiatrists on capacity. If the will fails, the earlier will is admitted to probate, or if there is none, the estate passes on intestacy. Many challenges resolve once the records are obtained, because they either support capacity clearly or show a problem the propounder cannot overcome.

Costs

Costs in probate litigation are in the court’s discretion. Where the testator’s own conduct, such as making a will in circumstances that invited doubt, caused the litigation, costs are often ordered from the estate. Where the challenger had reasonable grounds to investigate, each party may bear their own costs. Where a challenge was pursued without reasonable grounds, the challenger pays. A challenger should have the medical evidence assessed before committing to a trial.

A different question

Challenging the validity of a will is different from a family provision claim, which accepts that the will is valid but asks for provision from the estate. The two are often run together, and the nine month time limit for family provision applies regardless of a pending validity challenge.

Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.

Sources

The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.

This article is general information about the law as it applies in Queensland and was last updated on 11 November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not take account of your circumstances. Time limits and monetary limits change, so obtain advice on your own situation before acting.

Start an enquiry

Tell us what happened.

A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.

New enquiries
Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
Existing clients
(07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
Where we act
Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
What to have ready
Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.

Please complete the highlighted fields before sending.

Confidential. A lawyer reads every enquiry before we reply. Documents can be sent once the first step is confirmed.

Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.

A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.