People who have been left out of a will, or left less than a sibling, often describe the result as unfair. Family provision law does not ask whether the will was fair. It asks whether the applicant was left without adequate provision for their proper maintenance and support, and if so, what the deceased ought to have provided. The distinction shapes every one of these cases.
The two stage approach
Under section 41 of the Succession Act 1981 the court proceeds in two stages. At the first, jurisdictional stage it decides whether the provision made for the applicant, by the will or on intestacy, was inadequate for their proper maintenance and support. That is assessed at the date of the hearing, taking into account the applicant’s financial position, their health and age, their relationship with the deceased, the size and nature of the estate, and the competing claims of others. If the provision was adequate, the application fails whatever the applicant’s disappointment.
At the second stage, if provision was inadequate, the court decides what provision ought to be made, exercising a wide discretion to order a lump sum, a share of the estate, a life interest or other provision. The court does not rewrite the will to achieve equality between children or to reward loyalty; it makes the minimum provision that is adequate in the circumstances, leaving the deceased’s wishes otherwise intact.
Need
Need is the dominant consideration. An applicant who owns a home, has an adequate income and no dependants will struggle to show that the provision made for them was inadequate, even where they were omitted entirely. An applicant with health problems, insecure housing, debts, children to support or a limited earning capacity has a strong foundation. Proper maintenance is judged by the applicant’s station in life and the standard the deceased could have supported, not by subsistence, so a comfortable but insecure applicant can still succeed in a large estate.
The size of the estate
A small estate cannot do much. Where the estate is modest and the main beneficiary, often a surviving spouse, needs it for their own support, a child’s claim may fail even where the child has some need. A large estate changes the calculus and makes provision for several claimants possible. Costs are also a function of estate size; in a small estate they can consume what is being fought over.
Competing claims
The court weighs the claims of every beneficiary and every other applicant. A surviving spouse’s claim to secure accommodation and income generally takes priority over an adult child’s claim. The position of other children, particularly those who are themselves in need or who cared for the deceased, matters. A beneficiary with no moral claim, such as a distant relative or a charity, is more easily displaced than a spouse or a dependent child.
Relationship, estrangement and conduct
A close relationship supports a claim. Estrangement does not, on its own, defeat one, particularly where the deceased caused or contributed to it, but a long estrangement initiated and maintained by the applicant reduces what the court will order and can justify no provision at all. Section 41(2) allows the court to refuse an application where the applicant’s character or conduct disentitles them to the benefit of an order, which requires conduct of some seriousness directed at the deceased, not mere distance.
The deceased’s reasons
A will or an accompanying statement that explains why a person was excluded is admissible and is considered. The weight it carries depends on whether the reasons were accurate and whether they bear on the applicant’s need. A reason that is factually wrong, or that reflects a grievance rather than the applicant’s circumstances, carries little weight. A reason that the applicant has been adequately provided for during the deceased’s lifetime, or has received substantial gifts, is relevant and can be decisive.
Contributions and promises
Contributions the applicant made to the deceased’s estate or welfare, such as unpaid work in a business, care in old age or financial support, strengthen a claim. Promises by the deceased that the applicant would be provided for are relevant to what proper provision is and can, where the applicant relied on them to their detriment, ground a separate claim in estoppel that does not depend on the Act.
Costs
Costs are discretionary. A successful applicant usually recovers costs from the estate, though not always in full. An unsuccessful applicant may be ordered to pay the estate’s costs, and the practice of ordering all costs from the estate regardless of outcome has given way to a more conventional approach in which a claim with poor prospects carries real risk. Offers to settle made during the proceeding affect costs, and a party who refuses a reasonable offer and does no better at trial pays for it.
The practical picture
Most family provision claims settle at mediation, which the courts require before a hearing. A realistic assessment of need, estate size and competing claims at the outset allows an applicant to make or accept an offer that reflects the likely outcome without the cost of a trial.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.