1. Home
  2. What we help with
  3. Negligence claims
  4. Claims against tradespeople and contractors
Negligence claims

Claims against tradespeople and contractors

The plumber left a fitting loose and the house flooded while you were away. The arborist dropped a limb through the roof. The earthmover cut through the water main, or the pest controller sprayed the wrong product and killed the garden. Tradespeople owe a duty to do their work with reasonable care, and when careless work causes damage the law makes them, and usually their insurer, pay for it. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on where you stand.

Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.

  • Two basesA tradesperson engaged by you is liable in negligence for careless work and under the consumer guarantee that services be rendered with due care and skill, which cannot be excluded.
  • Consequential lossDamage caused by careless work, such as flooding, fire or damage to other property, is recoverable as well as the cost of redoing the work.
  • Proportionate liabilityWhere the work was for a business rather than a home, more than one wrongdoer may each be liable only for their share, so every contributor should be identified before the claim is brought.
  • ForumQCAT up to $25,000, the Magistrates Court up to $150,000 and the District Court above that. Claims must generally be brought within 6 years.

The disputes we see most

  • A tradesperson's work failed and caused water, fire or other damage to your home or property.
  • A contractor damaged your property, your neighbour's property or underground services while doing the job.
  • A tree lopper, landscaper or earthmover caused damage well beyond the job they were engaged to do.
  • A mechanic, panel beater or service agent damaged your vehicle, boat or machinery or caused a failure.
  • A removalist, cleaner or installer damaged furniture, flooring or fittings and will not pay.
  • The tradesperson has told you to claim on your own insurance, or their insurer has denied the claim.

Negligence and the consumer guarantee

A tradesperson engaged to do work on your home, land, vehicle or equipment owes two overlapping obligations. In negligence, they must take the care a reasonably competent tradesperson in their field would take, and they are liable for damage caused by falling short. Under the Australian Consumer Law, where the services cost $100,000 or less or are of a kind ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic or household use, they also guarantee that the services will be rendered with due care and skill and will be fit for any purpose you made known, and those guarantees cannot be excluded or limited by the contract. The guarantee is often the easier route for the person who engaged the tradesperson, while negligence is the route for a neighbour or other third party whose property was damaged. A tradesperson who causes damage in the course of the work, as opposed to doing the work badly, is liable for that damage in the same way.

The Civil Liability Act 2003 frames the negligence analysis. A person is not negligent for failing to take precautions against a risk unless the risk was foreseeable and not insignificant and a reasonable person in their position would have taken the precautions, having regard to the probability and seriousness of the harm, the burden of taking precautions and the social utility of the activity. For most tradesperson claims, the question is simply whether the work was done to the standard of the trade, and the evidence of another tradesperson or an expert answers it.

What can be recovered

The measure of loss is the cost of putting the claimant back in the position they would have been in had the work been done properly: the cost of redoing the careless work, the cost of repairing the damage it caused and the consequential losses that flow from it, such as alternative accommodation, loss of rent or hire of replacement equipment. The claimant must act reasonably to limit the loss. Where the claimant’s own insurer has paid for the damage, the insurer takes over the claim for what it paid and the claimant recovers the excess and any uninsured loss. The Act’s proportionate liability provisions, under which each of several wrongdoers is liable only for the share the court considers just, do not apply to claims by consumers, so a home owner can usually look to the tradesperson for the whole loss. Where the work was for a business, every contributor needs to be identified and, if necessary, joined.

Insurers

Most tradespeople carry public liability insurance that responds to damage their work causes. The insurer handles the claim on the tradesperson’s behalf and commonly disputes cause, quantum or coverage, in particular the distinction between the cost of the faulty work itself, which many policies exclude, and the resulting damage, which they cover. A demand that sets out the duty, the breach and the loss with supporting evidence puts the claim on a proper footing, and an insurer’s denial does not affect the tradesperson’s liability.

Where these disputes are decided

Claims up to $25,000 can be brought in QCAT as minor civil disputes or as consumer disputes against a trader. Larger claims go to the Magistrates Court up to $150,000 and the District Court up to $750,000, rising to $1.5 million from 1 January 2027. Claims must generally be started within 6 years of the damage occurring. Disputes about defective or incomplete residential building work by licensed contractors run through the Queensland Building and Construction Commission, and we do not act in them.

What usually happens

Our first step is a written advice on whether the tradesperson fell short, what you can recover and from whom. A demand to the tradesperson and their insurer, supported by the evidence, resolves many claims. Where it does not, we obtain the expert evidence, prepare the claim and quote each step before you commit to it.

What we do

  • Assess whether the tradesperson fell short of the standard of reasonable care and advise you in writing on what you can recover and from whom.
  • Prepare the demand to the tradesperson and their insurer, with the evidence of the failure and the loss.
  • Obtain expert reports where the cause of the damage or the standard of the work is disputed.
  • Prepare and run QCAT and court claims for the cost of rectification, the damage caused and consequential losses.
The first step is a fixed fee consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane. Tell us what happened using the enquiry form, and if we can help we will reply with the fee for that step before you pay anything. Once we receive payment, we open a file and complete the agreed work.

Common questions

What do I have to prove?

That the tradesperson owed you a duty of care, which anyone doing work on your property does, that their work fell below the standard a reasonably competent tradesperson in that trade would have met, and that the shortfall caused the damage you are claiming. Where you engaged them, you also have the Australian Consumer Law guarantee that the service be rendered with due care and skill, which does not require you to prove negligence in the same way and cannot be excluded by the contract. The evidence is photographs, the opinion of another tradesperson or an expert about what went wrong, and the invoices and quotes for the damage.

What can I recover?

The cost of putting right the careless work, the cost of repairing the damage it caused to your property and other losses that flow naturally from it, such as alternative accommodation while a flooded house dries out, loss of rent, or the hire of replacement equipment. Losses must be reasonable and you must take reasonable steps to limit them. Where the damage is covered by your own insurance, your insurer usually pays and then recovers from the tradesperson, and you can claim the excess and any uninsured loss directly.

The tradesperson says it was someone else's fault.

That may be partly right, and it matters. Under the Civil Liability Act 2003, where more than one person's carelessness caused the same damage to property or the same economic loss, each is generally liable only for the proportion the court considers just. Those proportionate liability provisions do not apply to a claim by a consumer, which includes an individual who engaged the tradesperson for work on their own home, so a home owner can usually recover the whole loss from the tradesperson and leave it to the tradesperson to seek a contribution from anyone else at fault. Where the work was for a business or an investment property, every potential contributor should be identified and, where necessary, included in the claim, because an uninsured or absent contributor's share may otherwise be lost.

Should I go through the tradesperson's insurer?

Usually yes, but on your terms. Most tradespeople carry public liability insurance that responds to damage their work causes to property. The claim is still against the tradesperson, and the insurer handles it on their behalf. Insurers frequently deny claims on the basis of policy exclusions, for example for faulty workmanship as opposed to resulting damage, or argue about cause and quantum. A well documented demand that sets out the legal basis and the evidence produces better results than an informal claim, and a denial by the insurer does not end your rights against the tradesperson.

What if the tradesperson has no insurance or has disappeared?

The claim can still be brought against them personally, and against their company if they trade through one. Whether a judgment can be enforced depends on their assets. Where a licensed contractor is involved and the problem is defective building work, the Queensland Building and Construction Commission's processes may apply instead, and we will tell you if your matter belongs there. Where another party also contributed to the loss, their share may be recoverable from them.

Where is the claim decided and how long do I have?

Claims up to $25,000 can be brought in QCAT as minor civil disputes, and consumer claims against a trader up to the same amount. Larger claims go to the Magistrates Court up to $150,000, and the District Court up to $750,000, rising to $1.5 million from 1 January 2027. A negligence claim must generally be started within 6 years of the damage occurring. Evidence disappears quickly in these cases, so photographs, the damaged components and the opinion of another tradesperson should be secured early.

This page is about Queensland law. Updated 11 November 2026.

Start an enquiry

Tell us what happened.

A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.

New enquiries
Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
Existing clients
(07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
Where we act
Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
What to have ready
Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.

Please complete the highlighted fields before sending.

Confidential. A lawyer reads every enquiry before we reply. Documents can be sent once the first step is confirmed.

Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.

A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.