Tradespeople work on property, and when the work goes wrong the damage is often far greater than the value of the job. A fitting left loose floods three rooms. A cable installed wrongly starts a fire. A tree limb dropped without a rope goes through the roof. These are negligence claims, and Queensland’s Civil Liability Act 2003 sets the framework for proving them. Fox Piper acts in claims for property damage caused by a tradesperson’s work; it does not act in disputes about defective building work, which follow a different path through the Queensland Building and Construction Commission.
Duty, breach and causation
A tradesperson owes a duty of care to the person whose property they work on, and to neighbours whose property is foreseeably at risk. Breach is governed by section 9 of the Act: a person is not negligent in failing to take precautions against a risk of harm unless the risk was foreseeable, meaning one the person knew or ought reasonably to have known, the risk was not insignificant, and in the circumstances a reasonable person in the person’s position would have taken the precautions. In deciding what a reasonable person would have done the court considers the probability of harm if care were not taken, its likely seriousness, the burden of taking precautions and the social utility of the activity. A tradesperson is judged by the standard of a competent member of their trade; the manufacturer’s installation instructions, the relevant Australian Standards and the trade’s ordinary practice define it.
Causation under section 11 requires that the breach was a necessary condition of the harm and that it is appropriate for the scope of the tradesperson’s liability to extend to the harm. The claimant bears the onus under section 12. In practice causation is proved by an expert report from another tradesperson or an engineer explaining what was done, what should have been done and how the failure produced the damage.
Damages
The measure of damages for property damage is the reasonable cost of reinstatement where that is reasonable in the circumstances, or the reduction in the property’s value where repair would be disproportionate. Consequential losses are recoverable where they were reasonably foreseeable: alternative accommodation while the house dries out, replacement of damaged contents, loss of rent from a tenanted property and the cost of expert investigation. The claimant must take reasonable steps to limit the loss, which means prompt drying, temporary repairs and not delaying the permanent repair unreasonably.
Contract and consumer law
Most tradespeople were engaged by the claimant under a contract, and the same facts give rise to a claim for breach of the contract’s express or implied terms and, where the claimant is a consumer, for breach of the guarantee in section 60 of the Australian Consumer Law that services will be rendered with due care and skill. Section 267 of that law entitles the consumer to damages for reasonably foreseeable loss caused by the failure. The claims are pleaded together, and the consumer law claim has the advantage that contributory negligence and exclusion clauses do not reduce it.
Proportionate liability and the consumer exclusion
Part 2 of chapter 2 of the Civil Liability Act makes claims for economic loss or property damage arising from a failure to take reasonable care apportionable among concurrent wrongdoers, so that each is liable only for the share the court considers just. Section 28(3)(b) excludes claims by a consumer from that regime. A home owner who engaged a tradesperson for personal, domestic or household purposes is a consumer for this purpose, and can recover the whole loss from the negligent tradesperson even where another party, such as a supplier of a faulty component or an earlier tradesperson, also contributed. The tradesperson then pursues the others for contribution. A commercial property owner, by contrast, is subject to apportionment and may need to sue everyone involved.
Contributory negligence
Sections 23 and 24 allow damages to be reduced where the claimant’s own lack of care contributed to the loss, and permit a reduction of 100 per cent where that is just. A property owner who ignored a visible leak for weeks, or who instructed the tradesperson to do the work in an unsafe way, can expect a reduction. Contributory negligence does not apply to the consumer law claim.
Insurance
Tradespeople carry public liability insurance, and the insurer will usually take over the defence. Claims should be notified to the tradesperson in writing promptly so that they can notify the insurer, and correspondence will then come from the insurer or its lawyers. The claimant’s own home insurer may pay for the damage and pursue the tradesperson by subrogation, which is often the quickest route and leaves the claimant to recover only the excess and uninsured losses.
Time limits and forum
Under section 10 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 the claim must be started within six years of the damage occurring. Claims up to $25,000 against a trader are minor civil disputes in QCAT; larger claims go to the Magistrates Court up to $150,000 and the District Court above that. The expert report should be obtained before the damage is repaired, or the repair documented thoroughly with photographs and retained parts.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.