A pre purchase inspection is bought for one reason: to find out what is wrong with a property before committing to buy it. When a buyer moves in and discovers termite damage, a failing roof or structural movement that the report did not mention, the question is whether the inspector should have found it. Often they should have, and the law provides a remedy.
The inspector’s duty
A building or pest inspector engaged by a buyer owes a duty in contract, in negligence and under the Australian Consumer Law to carry out the inspection with the care and skill of a competent inspector and to report what such an inspection would reveal. Section 22 of the Civil Liability Act 2003 provides that a professional does not breach their duty if they acted in a way that was widely accepted by peer professional opinion as competent professional practice, unless the court considers that opinion irrational. Inspectors rely on this, and on the Australian Standards for pre purchase inspections, which define a visual, non invasive inspection of accessible areas. A claim succeeds where the defect was visible or detectable in an accessible area at the time of inspection and a competent inspector would have identified and reported it, or would have recommended further investigation of indicators that were present.
The report’s limitations
Every inspection report contains exclusions: areas not accessible, items not inspected, limitations on the inspection, and recommendations for further specialist assessment. Those terms are part of the contract and define the scope of the duty. A claim for a defect in a roof void the inspector could not enter and said so is unlikely to succeed. A claim for termite damage behind a wall lining the inspector could not see is unlikely to succeed unless there were external indicators, such as mud leads, moisture or damaged timber elsewhere, that a competent inspector would have noted and followed up. A claim will also fail where the report did identify the problem, or recommended a further inspection the buyer did not obtain.
Contract terms that attempt to cap the inspector’s liability at the fee, or to exclude liability altogether, are of limited effect. The consumer guarantees of due care and skill and fitness for purpose cannot be excluded, and a cap in a standard form consumer contract is exposed to the unfair contract terms provisions.
Proving the claim
The claimant needs the original report, photographs of the defects as found, and a report from an independent inspector or engineer addressing two questions: what was the condition of the property at the date of the original inspection, and would a competent inspector have found and reported it. The second report should be obtained before rectification, or the defects documented in detail before they are repaired. The inspector will say the damage occurred or became visible after the inspection, so evidence of its age matters: termite damage, for example, has a timeline that an entomologist can estimate.
Damages
The usual measure is the reasonable cost of rectifying the defects that should have been reported, because that puts the buyer in the position they would have been in had the report been accurate and they had negotiated or been compensated accordingly. An alternative measure is the difference between the price paid and the property’s value with the defects disclosed, which applies where the buyer would not have bought at all. Consequential losses, such as alternative accommodation during repairs and the cost of the investigating expert, are recoverable. The buyer cannot recover for defects the report did disclose, or for a general improvement of the property.
Proportionate liability does not reduce a consumer’s claim
The inspector will often argue that the seller, the seller’s agent or a prior builder also caused the loss and that liability should be apportioned under part 2 of chapter 2 of the Civil Liability Act. Section 28(3)(b) excludes claims by consumers from that regime. A buyer who engaged the inspector for the purchase of their home is a consumer, so the inspector is liable for the whole of the loss caused by the negligent inspection and must pursue others for contribution. An investor buying a rental property may be treated differently and should take advice on the point.
Why the inspector rather than the builder
Buyers sometimes ask whether they can sue the original builder instead. For a later purchaser that is difficult. The High Court has confined the duty of care a builder owes to subsequent owners for pure economic loss to cases where the purchaser was genuinely vulnerable and unable to protect themselves. The Queensland Court of Appeal applied that approach in Raymond v Lewis [2024] QCA 43. The buyer there had been given the seller’s building and pest reports, which noted that inaccessible areas were not inspected, and did not obtain her own inspection before the auction; because the subfloor defects were found quickly by inspectors she engaged after settlement, the court held they were discoverable before purchase, that she was not vulnerable and that the builder owed her no duty, at [52] to [58]. The decision underlines why the practical remedy for a buyer who did commission an inspection usually lies against the inspector who missed what should have been found.
Misleading conduct
Statements in a report that the property is in good condition or free of termite activity are representations, and where they were made without reasonable basis they can found a claim under section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law, which does not require proof of negligence and is not reduced for contributory negligence.
Time limits
Under section 10 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 the claim must be started within six years of the loss, which generally runs from the purchase in reliance on the report. Buyers who discover defects years later should act promptly. Claims up to $25,000 go to QCAT, larger claims to the Magistrates Court up to $150,000 and the District Court above that. Inspectors carry professional indemnity insurance, and the claim should be notified in writing so the insurer can be involved.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.