1. Home
  2. Articles
  3. Negligence claims
Negligence claims

Defending a negligence claim for property damage or economic loss

A tradesperson, inspector, adviser or property owner accused of causing loss through carelessness has more defences than the demand letter suggests. This article explains what the claimant must prove under the Civil Liability Act 2003, the defences available, insurance notification and the limitation defence.

A letter arrives alleging that your work, your report or your property caused someone a loss, demanding payment and threatening proceedings. The instinct is either to apologise and offer something or to deny everything. Both are mistakes at that stage. A negligence claim has several elements, each of which the claimant must prove, and the Civil Liability Act 2003 provides defences that frequently reduce or defeat claims that look strong in a demand letter.

What the claimant must prove

Under section 9 the claimant must show that the risk of harm was foreseeable, that it was not insignificant, and that a reasonable person in your position would have taken the precautions alleged, having regard to the probability and seriousness of the harm, the burden of the precautions and the social utility of what you were doing. Hindsight is excluded: section 10 provides that the subsequent taking of action that would have avoided the risk does not of itself amount to an admission, and the question is what was reasonable at the time. Under section 11 the claimant must prove that the breach was a necessary condition of the harm and that it is appropriate for your liability to extend to it, and section 12 places the onus on the claimant. A defendant can contest each element, and causation is often the weakest point of a claim: the damage may have occurred anyway, may have another cause, or may have been caused by a later event.

Peer professional opinion

Section 22 provides that a professional does not breach a duty in providing a professional service if it is established that they acted in a way that, at the time, was widely accepted by peer professional opinion by a significant number of respected practitioners in the field as competent professional practice. The court may disregard that opinion only if it is irrational or contrary to a written law. The defence does not extend to a failure to warn or give information. Building inspectors, engineers, valuers, surveyors and other professionals rely on it, and the evidence is from practitioners in the field about accepted practice, supported by any applicable standards and codes.

Contributory negligence and mitigation

Sections 23 and 24 allow damages to be reduced, up to 100 per cent, where the claimant’s own failure to take care contributed to the loss. The claimant’s knowledge, the warnings given, the instructions provided and the claimant’s conduct after the problem emerged are all relevant. Separately, a claimant must take reasonable steps to limit the loss once it is known, and the cost of delay, of unreasonable repairs or of a failure to make a claim on their own insurer where that was the sensible course can be excluded from the damages.

Proportionate liability

Where the claim is for economic loss or property damage arising from a failure to take reasonable care and the claimant is not a consumer, part 2 of chapter 2 limits your liability to the proportion of the loss that reflects your responsibility. Other concurrent wrongdoers, such as the designer, the supplier, another contractor or the claimant’s own advisers, must be identified in the defence, and you are obliged to give the claimant information about them. Where the claimant is a consumer, meaning under section 29 an individual whose claim relates to goods or services being acquired for personal, domestic or household use, or to professional advice given for their own rather than business use, apportionment is unavailable and your remedy against others is a claim for contribution. In Queensland the parties cannot contract out of proportionate liability, because section 7(3) excludes chapter 2 part 2 from the general freedom to vary the Act by contract.

Contract terms

If you were engaged under a contract, its terms define the scope of what you undertook, and limitations of scope, exclusions and caps are enforceable against a business claimant to the extent the general law allows. Against a consumer, terms excluding the consumer guarantees are void and caps may be unfair terms, but scope limitations still define what you were engaged to do.

Apologies

Section 72D provides that an expression of regret or apology made in connection with a matter alleged to have been caused by the person does not constitute an admission of liability and is not relevant to the determination of fault. You can say you are sorry the loss occurred. You should not say that you made a mistake, explain what you did wrong or offer to pay before taking advice, because statements of fact are not protected.

Insurance

Notify your public liability or professional indemnity insurer as soon as you become aware of a claim or of circumstances that might give rise to one. Policies require it, late notification can prejudice cover and the insurer will usually appoint lawyers and manage the defence. Do not admit liability or make offers without the insurer’s consent; most policies prohibit it.

Limitation

A claim for property damage or economic loss must be started within six years of the loss under section 10 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974. Where the demand relates to work done long ago, the limitation defence should be checked first; it must be pleaded, and it is a complete answer.

Responding

Acknowledge the letter briefly, say that the matter has been referred for advice and to your insurer, and preserve every document, including photographs, job records, communications and any materials or parts. Then have the claim assessed against each element. Many demands are reduced to a fraction, or withdrawn, once the claimant is required to prove breach and causation and faces contributory negligence and apportionment arguments.

Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.

Sources

The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.

This article is general information about the law as it applies in Queensland and was last updated on 11 November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not take account of your circumstances. Time limits and monetary limits change, so obtain advice on your own situation before acting.

Start an enquiry

Tell us what happened.

A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.

New enquiries
Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
Existing clients
(07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
Where we act
Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
What to have ready
Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.

Please complete the highlighted fields before sending.

Confidential. A lawyer reads every enquiry before we reply. Documents can be sent once the first step is confirmed.

Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.

A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.