Fault in a property damage or economic loss claim is rarely all on one side. The claimant may have contributed to their own loss, and more than one person may have caused it. The Civil Liability Act 2003 contains two sets of rules for those situations, and they determine not only how much a claimant recovers but who the claimant needs to sue.
Contributory negligence
Sections 23 and 24 deal with the claimant’s own carelessness. The standard of care expected of the claimant is that of a reasonable person in their position, judged on what they knew or ought to have known. Where the claimant’s failure to take care for their own interests contributed to the loss, damages are reduced by the proportion the court considers just and equitable having regard to the claimant’s share in the responsibility. Section 24 provides that the court may reduce damages by 100 per cent if it considers that just, which means a claimant whose own conduct was overwhelmingly the cause can recover nothing even though the defendant was also negligent.
Typical examples in property claims are an owner who ignored obvious warning signs, who failed to follow clear instructions, who interfered with work in progress or who delayed repairs so that damage spread. Contributory negligence applies to claims in negligence and, by section 23, to claims for breach of a contractual duty of care that is concurrent with the duty in tort. It does not apply to claims for breach of the consumer guarantees under the Australian Consumer Law or to deceit.
Proportionate liability
Part 2 of chapter 2 of the Act replaces the old rule that each wrongdoer was liable for the whole loss with proportionate liability for apportionable claims. Section 28 defines an apportionable claim as a claim for economic loss or damage to property in an action for damages arising from a breach of a duty of care, and a claim for economic loss or property damage under the misleading conduct provisions of the Australian Consumer Law and its state equivalent. A concurrent wrongdoer is a person who is one of two or more persons whose acts or omissions caused, independently or jointly, the loss that is the subject of the claim.
Under section 31 the liability of a defendant who is a concurrent wrongdoer is limited to the proportion of the loss the court considers just having regard to the extent of their responsibility, and the court may have regard to the responsibility of a concurrent wrongdoer who is not a party, including one who is dead, insolvent or cannot be found. The consequence is that the claimant, not the defendant, bears the risk that one of the wrongdoers cannot pay. Section 32 prevents a defendant whose liability has been apportioned from being required to contribute to another wrongdoer’s share.
Who the claimant must sue
Because each defendant is liable only for their share, a claimant in an apportionable claim needs to identify and sue every person who contributed to the loss. A defendant who wishes to rely on the responsibility of another person must give the claimant information identifying them. Commercial claimants in building, professional advice and investment matters must plan their proceedings around this, and the cost of suing several defendants is part of the calculus.
The consumer exclusion
Section 28(3)(b) provides that the proportionate liability provisions do not apply to a claim by a consumer. Section 29 defines a consumer for this purpose as an individual whose claim is based on rights relating to goods or services that are being acquired for personal, domestic or household use or consumption, or that relate to advice given by a professional to the individual for their own use rather than for a business they carry on. A home owner suing a tradesperson, a buyer suing a building inspector about their home, or a person suing an adviser about a personal matter is a consumer, and the ordinary rule applies: each wrongdoer is liable for the whole loss, and the claimant can sue one and leave them to seek contribution from the others. That is a substantial practical advantage, and it is the reason individuals in these disputes can often sue a single well insured defendant.
Fraud and intentional wrongdoing
Section 32D provides that a concurrent wrongdoer against whom a finding of fraud is made is severally liable for the damages awarded against every other concurrent wrongdoer, and section 32E applies the same rule to a wrongdoer found to have intended to cause the loss. A claimant who can prove fraud or intention against one defendant is therefore not limited to that defendant’s proportionate share.
Contracting out
Queensland differs from New South Wales and some other States on this point. Section 7(3) of the Act allows contracting parties to make their own provision for their rights and liabilities on matters the Act deals with, but it expressly excludes chapter 2 part 2, which contains the proportionate liability provisions, from that freedom. A clause in a Queensland contract purporting to exclude proportionate liability or to make the parties jointly and severally liable for an apportionable claim will not be effective, and the apportionment rules apply regardless of what the contract says. Contracts governed by the law of another State may produce a different result, so the governing law clause should be checked.
In practice
For an individual home owner, these rules mean that contributory negligence is the main risk to the recovery and that the claim can be brought against the party most able to pay. For a business, they mean identifying every potential wrongdoer early, obtaining the expert evidence that allocates responsibility between them and making a realistic assessment of what each can pay before the claim is framed.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.