- Home
- What we help with
- Negligence claims
- Defending a negligence claim against you
Defending a negligence claim against you
A letter arrives saying your tree, your contractor, your excavation, your burn off or your report caused someone's loss, and demanding a large sum within 14 days. Being accused of negligence does not mean you were negligent, and even where something went wrong the amount claimed is often far more than the law would award. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on where you stand and what to do first.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- Insurance firstIf you have home, landlord, farm, public liability or professional indemnity insurance, notify the insurer before responding. Late notice can prejudice cover, and the insurer usually conducts the defence.
- The claimant must prove itThe claimant must prove a duty, a failure to take reasonable care, causation and the amount of the loss. Each is a point at which claims fail or shrink.
- Sharing the blameWhere the claimant's own carelessness contributed, damages are reduced. Where others also caused the loss, you may be liable only for your share, unless the claimant is a consumer.
- Offers and costsA properly framed settlement offer protects you on costs if the claimant presses on and does no better at trial.
The disputes we see most
- A neighbour claims your tree, your works, your water or your fire damaged their property.
- A client or customer claims your work, your inspection or your advice caused them loss.
- Someone claims your stock, your vehicle or your equipment caused damage.
- You have received a letter of demand with a short deadline and a large figure.
- You have been served with a QCAT application or a court claim.
- Your insurer has declined to cover the claim, or you have no insurance.
What a claimant must prove
A person who claims that your carelessness damaged their property or caused them financial loss must prove four things: that you owed them a duty of care, that you failed to take the care a reasonable person in your position would have taken, that your failure caused the loss, and the amount of the loss. The Civil Liability Act 2003 shapes each. You are not negligent for failing to take precautions against a risk unless it was foreseeable and not insignificant and a reasonable person would have taken the precautions, having regard to the probability and seriousness of the harm, the burden of taking precautions and the social utility of the activity. Causation requires that your failure was a necessary condition of the harm and that it is appropriate for your responsibility to extend to it. The claimant must prove the loss with evidence, and must have taken reasonable steps to limit it. Every one of those elements is a point at which claims fail or shrink, and a demand that asserts liability in confident terms frequently cannot establish all of them.
Contribution, apportionment and time
Where the claimant’s own carelessness contributed to their loss, the court reduces their damages by the proportion it considers just, and can in a clear case reduce them to nothing. Where more than one person caused the same property damage or economic loss, the Act’s proportionate liability provisions limit each wrongdoer’s liability to the share the court considers just, provided the other wrongdoers are identified, although those provisions do not apply where the claimant is a consumer who acquired the goods or services for personal or household use, in which case the defendant may have to pay the whole loss and seek contribution from the others. A defendant who engaged a contractor whose work caused the damage, or whose neighbour’s works contributed to it, should raise that at the outset. A negligence claim for property damage or economic loss must generally be started within 6 years of the damage occurring, and a late claim can be defended on that ground alone.
Insurance
Most people facing a negligence claim have insurance that responds to it. Home and contents, landlord, farm, business and public liability policies commonly cover legal liability for damage to other people’s property, and professional indemnity policies cover claims arising from professional services. The insurer should be notified as soon as a claim or a circumstance likely to give rise to one is known, before any response is sent, because the policy will usually require it and will give the insurer the right to conduct the defence and to settle. Admitting liability or settling without the insurer’s consent can forfeit cover. Under the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 late notification does not automatically defeat a claim for indemnity, but the insurer may reduce its liability to the extent it was prejudiced. Where an insurer declines cover, that decision can be challenged, and we act in those disputes.
Resolving the claim
Most negligence claims about property damage settle. A defendant who may have some exposure can take control by making a written offer to settle, either under the court rules or on a without prejudice save as to costs basis. If the claimant rejects it and does not do better at trial, the court will usually order the claimant to pay the defendant’s costs from the date of the offer, which transfers the risk of continuing onto the claimant. Claims that are filed must be answered within the time allowed, because a default decision in QCAT or a default judgment in court can be entered and enforced without any hearing of the merits.
Where these disputes are decided
Claims up to $25,000 are brought in QCAT as minor civil disputes. Larger claims go to the Magistrates Court up to $150,000, the District Court up to $750,000, rising to $1.5 million from 1 January 2027, and the Supreme Court above that. We do not act in personal injury claims, which run under different legislation.
What usually happens
Our first step is a written advice on your exposure, your defences and the sensible range for resolution, together with the insurance position. We prepare the response, deal with the insurer and, where the claim does not resolve, run the defence and quote each step before you commit to it.
What we do
- Review the demand or the claim and the evidence and advise you in writing on your exposure, your defences and the sensible range for resolution.
- Notify and liaise with your insurer, and act for you where the insurer declines cover or where there is a gap between the claim and the cover.
- Prepare the response, identifying the defences, the claimant's own contribution and any other parties who share responsibility.
- Prepare and run the defence in QCAT or the courts, including settlement offers framed to protect you on costs.
Common questions
I have received a letter of demand. What do I do first?
Do not ignore it and do not admit anything. Check every insurance policy you hold, because home and contents, landlord, farm, business and public liability policies commonly cover liability for damage to other people's property, and notify the insurer promptly. Preserve the evidence, including photographs and documents, and do not alter the site or the thing complained of beyond what safety requires. Then obtain advice before responding, because the response sets the tone and a careless admission is hard to retrieve.
Why does the insurer matter so much?
Because a liability policy both pays the claim and pays for the defence, and the insurer usually has the right to conduct the defence and to settle. A policyholder who admits liability, settles or incurs costs without the insurer's consent may lose cover. Late notification is not automatically fatal under the Insurance Contracts Act 1984, but the insurer can reduce its liability to the extent it was prejudiced. If the insurer declines cover, that decision can itself be disputed, and we act in those disputes as well.
What defences are there?
The claimant must prove that you owed them a duty, that you failed to take reasonable care, that your failure caused the loss and what the loss is worth. Any of those can be contested. Under the Civil Liability Act 2003, you are not negligent for failing to guard against a risk that was not foreseeable or was insignificant, or where a reasonable person would not have taken the precaution given its burden. The claimant's own carelessness reduces their damages. Where others contributed to the loss, you may be liable only for your share. Many claims also overstate the loss, for example by claiming the cost of a new fence for an old one, or consequential losses that were avoidable. And a claim brought more than 6 years after the damage is generally out of time.
What if I was partly at fault?
Then the task is to make sure you pay only what the law requires. Contributory negligence reduces the claimant's damages by the share of responsibility the court attributes to them. Proportionate liability means that where another person, such as a contractor you engaged, also caused the damage, the court apportions responsibility and you pay only your proportion, provided the other person is identified and the claimant is not a consumer, in which case you may have to pay the whole loss and seek a contribution from the other person. A sensible early offer, properly framed, often resolves a claim where some liability is likely for far less than was demanded.
How do settlement offers protect me on costs?
If you make a written offer to settle, in the form the court rules provide or on a without prejudice save as to costs basis, and the claimant rejects it and then fails to do better at trial, the court will usually order the claimant to pay your costs from the date of the offer, even though they won. That consequence makes a well judged offer the most powerful tool a defendant has, because it transfers the costs risk of continuing to the claimant. Offers should be made early and framed carefully.
What happens if I do nothing?
If a claim is filed in QCAT or a court and you do not respond within the time allowed, the claimant can obtain a default decision or judgment for the amount claimed without any hearing of the merits, and enforce it against your wages, bank accounts and property. Setting a default judgment aside is possible but costs money and requires a good explanation and an arguable defence. A demand can be ignored at your peril; a filed claim cannot be ignored at all.
Articles on defending a negligence claim
A longer answer to one of the questions people ask us most often about defending a negligence claim. It sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.